Nothing seems to have changed in the 43 years since the establishment of the illegal political entity in the occupied territories of Cyprus. The island remains divided in two, with the Turkish army controlling 37% of the territory of a European state.
Last week, in the occupied territories of Cyprus, the establishment of the so-called “Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus” was celebrated, at a time when only a few people in Europe continue to demand what they consider to be the self-evident solution: liberation rather than federation, and the rejection of a two-state or two-entity arrangement.
What has been the response of the European Union itself? What pressure has it exerted on Turkey over all these years, from the 1974 invasion to the present day, given that Turkey continues to be regarded by many as the central obstacle in negotiations to resolve the Cyprus problem? Is this, as many have sought to portray it in recent years, simply a dispute between two communities (Greek Cypriots and Turkish Cypriots)?
To begin with, we must acknowledge that the Cyprus problem is fundamentally an issue of invasion and occupation. In 1974, Turkey invaded Cyprus and seized 37% of the island, drawing a dividing line across its territory. Fifty-two years later, the situation remains largely unchanged, with successive administrations in the so-called Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus, acting under Ankara’s influence, continuing to advocate partition-based solutions, whether through a two-state arrangement or a Bi-zonal, Bi-communal Federation (BBF). Such proposals, according to this perspective, would neither resolve the problem nor reunify Cyprus.
Beyond the humanitarian crisis — involving refugees who lost their homes, missing persons and displaced people — Cyprus remains home to Europe’s last divided capital. Nicosia bears deep scars and stands as a visible reminder of the ongoing division and the lack of progress towards a settlement.
We must also remember that Turkey has violated fundamental provisions of the Charter of the United Nations (UN), as well as numerous binding resolutions of the UN Security Council.
The UN Charter stipulates that all UN member states must refrain from the threat or use of force against the territorial integrity or political independence of any state. Turkey’s military invasion in 1974, however, clearly violated this fundamental principle, since the 1960 Treaty of Guarantee did not grant the right to unilateral military intervention for the purpose of dismantling Cyprus’s territorial integrity.
The solutions proposed to the Greek Cypriot side over the years have been far from sustainable. From this perspective, the only thing a federal arrangement can achieve in a situation such as the Cyprus problem is to legitimise the principle that might makes right. In other words, whoever possesses the military power and capabilities can lay claim to and seize the territory of another country.
Is Federation the Solution?
For a federation to be established, certain criteria must first be met, including the territorial definition of its constituent entities. This is not the case in Cyprus, where the division was imposed following the Turkish invasion and occupation.
At the same time, a divided Cyprus based on a federal model raises questions concerning the prohibition of racial discrimination under the rules of jus cogens (peremptory norms of international law). Under the Vienna Convention of 1980, any international agreement that provides for such violations would be rendered invalid. Furthermore, there would remain a risk of polarisation between the regions making up the state, potentially creating divisive rather than unifying tendencies.
In conclusion, as members of the European Union, we must remember that, according to this position, there is only one solution: a unified state. The Cyprus problem is not merely an issue concerning Cyprus; it is also a European issue, since the occupied territories are not only part of Cyprus but also part of European territory.
There is now a clear need for the other European states to support Cyprus in addressing the humanitarian problems caused by the Turkish invasion and occupation.
Yesterday it was Cyprus; today it is Ukraine. Whose territory will be next to become the subject of negotiations and bargaining? The principles of justice and international law in Europe are being tested in the occupied territories of Cyprus, and this is something that all European Union member states must clearly understand.