Smartphones banned, artificial intelligence prohibited, and one demanding book to read every week. At Harvard, the unexpected success of Humanities 10 tells a truth that digital society risks forgetting: not everything that can be automated necessarily should be.
There is something surprising about the news coming from Harvard. At a time when artificial intelligence promises to make every intellectual activity easier, a university course that bans smartphones, computers, and AI tools has recorded a 40 percent increase in enrollment. It is called Humanities 10, is designed for freshmen, and offers a far from light academic journey: one demanding book to read every week, regular essays, mandatory participation, and constant discussion with professors and fellow students. In the fall of 2026, 180 students applied for just 90 available places. The program spans centuries of thought and literature, from Homer and Plato to Montaigne, Shakespeare, Spinoza, Jane Austen, and James Baldwin. It is not simply a journey through the great authors, but an educational experience that requires time, concentration, and a willingness to engage with complex ideas.
The course was established in 2008 by professors Stephen Greenblatt and Louis Menand, with the aim of restoring the centrality of the humanities in an academic environment increasingly oriented toward other fields. Nearly twenty years later, the project seems to have acquired an even more relevant meaning. Precisely when digital tools make it possible to produce texts, summaries, and answers in a matter of seconds, a growing number of students are deliberately choosing a path that requires them to slow down. As reported by the Wall Street Journal and subsequently covered by the Italian press, the success of Humanities 10 does not appear to be connected to immediate academic advantages, but rather to a desire for an authentic educational experience in which thinking cannot be delegated to a machine.
The story deserves attention because it challenges one of the most deeply rooted assumptions of our time: the idea that progress necessarily coincides with reducing effort. For years, we have identified efficiency with speed, considering waiting, effort, and even difficulty as obstacles to be eliminated. Technology has certainly improved our lives, expanded access to information, and made previously unimaginable activities possible. However, when this logic is transferred indiscriminately to education, it risks creating a profound misunderstanding: confusing the result with the process necessary to achieve it.
A summary can convey the content of a book, but it cannot replace the experience of reading it. An answer can be correct without the person receiving it having understood the reasoning behind it. An essay can appear convincing without its author having genuinely exercised the ability to argue. This is where the issue of artificial intelligence moves beyond a simple technological debate and becomes an educational and anthropological question. We should not ask ourselves only what a machine can do in our place, but also what we risk no longer being able to do if we stop practicing it.
Reading a complex work means learning to tolerate ambiguity, recognize contradictions, go back, and revise one’s interpretations. It means accepting that an important question does not necessarily have an immediate answer. It is an exercise in attention, but also in humility: a text does not always conform to our expectations and may force us to reconsider beliefs we had regarded as firmly established. Culture, in this sense, is not merely a storehouse of information to be consulted when needed. It is a discipline of the mind, a form of training that helps shape character and individual judgment.
There is something genuinely conservative about the experience proposed by Humanities 10, without the need to turn it into an ideological battle. Cultural conservatism, in its most serious expression, does not consist in rejecting the new or idealizing an imaginary past. It consists in recognizing that not everything worth preserving can be immediately replaced and that certain achievements of civilization require patient transmission from one generation to another.
Literature, philosophy, history, and the arts belong to this heritage. Not because every author of the past is necessarily right, nor because the classics should be revered without question. On the contrary, they remain important precisely because they can be questioned, challenged, and reinterpreted. Reading Plato does not mean becoming a Platonist, just as engaging with Montaigne does not imply agreeing with every conclusion he reached. It means entering into a conversation that began before our existence and will continue after us. A conversation in which we discover that seemingly contemporary issues, such as the relationship between the individual and the community, the meaning of freedom, the nature of power, and the responsibility for our actions, were addressed by men and women who lived centuries before us.
In an age that tends to regard every individual as self-sufficient and all knowledge as immediately available, tradition gives education a concrete meaning: it is not a chain that prevents us from moving forward, but a path that allows us not to start over endlessly. Freedom, after all, does not coincide with the absence of constraints. A person is truly free when they possess the tools to judge, distinguish, choose, and take responsibility for their decisions. And these tools are not acquired automatically: they are built through study, practice, and engagement with ideas that may be very different from one’s own.
It would nevertheless be wrong to interpret Harvard’s choice as a condemnation of artificial intelligence. New technologies can offer extraordinary opportunities in research, information organization, and learning. They can help us understand a text, identify alternative interpretations, and formulate new questions. The problem arises when assistance turns into substitution. If a student uses artificial intelligence to verify reasoning they have already developed, they can expand their possibilities. If, instead, they use it to avoid developing that reasoning altogether, they obtain a result without acquiring the skill that the result is supposed to demonstrate.
This is a decisive difference, especially in a future in which the production of content will become increasingly simple and accessible. The competitive advantage will not necessarily belong to those who know how to produce more quickly, but to those who are able to recognize what deserves to be produced, distinguish truth from falsehood, evaluate the relevance of information, and avoid confusing what appears plausible with what is actually well-founded. In a world saturated with answers, the ability to formulate the right questions could become one of the most valuable skills.
The story of Harvard ultimately contains an important message for schools. It is not enough to introduce new tools into classrooms, update platforms, or teach students how to use the latest technologies. We must preserve spaces in which knowledge is not reduced to an immediate performance, but becomes a personal experience. A young person must be able to learn to read without immediately searching for a summary, to write without delegating the construction of thought, and to discuss without relying on the first available answer. They must be able to make mistakes, correct themselves, defend an argument, and discover that their beliefs are not always sufficiently well-founded.
This does not mean nostalgically bringing back the school of the past, nor denying the value of innovation. It means avoiding the risk of turning innovation into an excuse for abandoning the essential functions of education. Schools must not merely prepare students to use the tools of the present: they must enable them to critically engage with those of the future as well. Technologies will change, some professions will disappear, and others will emerge. The ability to read, understand, judge, and argue, however, will continue to be fundamental.
Perhaps this is precisely the most interesting meaning of the success of Humanities 10: some students at one of the world’s most prestigious universities are not simply asking to learn something more, but to be challenged. They are choosing an experience that cannot be reduced to an automated result and that requires their presence, their attention, and their personal contribution.
Ultimately, there is also a form of freedom in effort. Because those who give up thinking inevitably allow others, or something else, to do it for them. And a society in which individuals stop exercising judgment risks becoming a society that is more easily influenced, even when it possesses increasingly sophisticated technological tools.
In a world that promises to spare us every effort, some students still choose the effort required to become genuinely capable. It is an encouraging sign. Perhaps the greatest luxury of the future will not be having all the answers at our fingertips, but retaining the ability to seek them, understand them, and, above all, having the courage not to settle for less.