A newspaper could once be silenced by confiscating its presses. Today, an algorithm can make an opinion disappear without anyone knowing who made the decision. The technologies that have expanded freedom of expression also create new opportunities to restrict it. And the question facing Europe is whether its response will protect citizens or place still more power in the hands of regulators and digital giants.
That dilemma shaped the opening panel of the Nordic Sidebar Forum on Freedom of Expression, held in Stockholm on November 13 and organised by the ECR Party. Under the moderation of Henrik Sundström, deputy mayor of Uddevalla, the discussion brought together Croatian MP and Most party president Nikola Grmoja, former Icelandic justice minister Sigríður Andersen, Unplugged CEO Joe Weil and Peter Caddle of Ireland’s Edmund Burke Institute.
The subject was ostensibly technical: the Digital Services Act (DSA), digital identity, online privacy and European regulation. But the underlying question was political. Who should decide the limits of citizens’ freedom: elected representatives and independent courts, or administrative institutions and private platforms?
Grmoja opened with a reference to Alexis de Tocqueville’s warning about a form of control exercised not through open tyranny but through an accumulation of small rules. “Who decides what you may say, read, pay with, and keep private?” he asked. “You or a system you cannot see and cannot vote out?”
His argument was not that the internet should be lawless. Rather, decisions affecting fundamental freedoms must remain accountable to citizens. For the Croatian politician, private messages should remain private, cash should remain available and the boundaries of lawful expression should not depend on opaque agreements between Brussels and technology companies.
When protecting citizens becomes controlling speech
The Digital Services Act is designed to make online platforms more accountable and tackle illegal content. Those objectives are legitimate. But the panel’s central concern was that regulatory pressure could encourage platforms to remove lawful material rather than risk sanctions.
Caddle highlighted the financial stakes. Under the DSA, serious breaches can carry fines of up to 6% of a company’s global annual turnover. For a major technology business, that represents an enormous potential cost. Even when legislation does not explicitly demand the removal of a particular opinion, he argued, the incentive may be to err on the side of restriction.
Grmoja went further. Most Croatian political debate, he observed, now takes place on a handful of American platforms. When their rules change, a citizen in Zagreb or Dubrovnik may discover that a post has vanished or its reach has fallen, without any meaningful explanation of who was responsible.
“If a post is illegal, a judge should say that,” he argued. “If it’s legal, nobody should bury it.”
The distinction matters. European democracies already have laws, constitutional guarantees and judicial procedures. The challenge is to enforce those safeguards in the digital world without creating a parallel system in which speech is effectively governed by corporate risk management.
Yet there is another risk that Europe cannot ignore: excessive regulation may undermine its ability to build the technologies it seeks to control.
A continent that regulates but struggles to innovate
Caddle delivered the sharpest warning on European competitiveness. Asked what a talented European entrepreneur should do to transform the digital sector, his answer was blunt: “Leave. You get out as fast as you can.”
His criticism centred on the burden of starting and growing technology businesses. Compliance costs, bureaucracy and fragmented barriers can make Europe less attractive than competing markets. Established corporations may be able to hire lawyers and specialists to navigate the rules; start-ups often cannot.
This creates a paradox. Brussels wants greater European technological independence, yet the regulatory environment can make it harder for European companies to challenge American and Asian competitors. At a time when artificial intelligence is transforming industry, defence and public services, Europe cannot afford to be merely the market that writes rules for technologies invented elsewhere.
Andersen approached the question from Iceland, which is outside the EU but participates in the European Economic Area and therefore adopts a substantial body of European legislation. She stressed how difficult it can be for policymakers to understand technologies that evolve faster than legislative institutions.
Her concern was not simply the volume of regulation. It was the gradual erosion of liberties through measures presented individually as minor or necessary. Constitutions, parliamentary scrutiny and the courts, she argued, must remain the foundations of any interference with citizens’ rights.
There was, however, no suggestion that technology itself is the enemy. Caddle recognised the practical benefits of data-driven services, including navigation tools and the potential of artificial intelligence. The goal should be to prevent abuse without preventing innovation.
Privacy is also a question of security
Joe Weil, CEO of Unplugged and a former Apple executive, introduced a dimension often missing from political debates about privacy: smartphones are not merely communication devices, but constant producers of information about our movements, habits and relationships.
He argued that privacy settings and restrictions on advertising identifiers address only part of the problem. Digital business models still create powerful incentives to gather data, and the information can be used for purposes far beyond personalised advertising.
Weil pointed to the wars in Ukraine and the Middle East to illustrate what is at stake. According to his account, commercially collected smartphone data can be turned into intelligence and potentially used to identify military targets. Artificial intelligence makes that process faster and less expensive.
His proposed answer was not another layer of bureaucracy but innovation: products and decentralised systems designed to protect privacy from the outset. In that sense, digital freedom is also becoming a question of European strategic autonomy. A continent unable to secure its information cannot credibly claim to control its own technological future.
The right to choose must survive digitisation
One of the most concrete exchanges concerned cash and digital identity. Grmoja described his party’s attempt to secure constitutional protection for cash payments in Croatia, including a referendum initiative.
“Cash is the last way to pay without asking permission,” he said. For him, the issue is not nostalgia for banknotes. Cash allows people to make ordinary transactions without relying on an app, a network connection or a permanent digital record. It also protects those who cannot, or do not wish to, use new technologies.
Supporters of the digital euro say it would complement rather than replace cash. Grmoja’s response was simple: if that commitment is genuine, it should be guaranteed in law. Similar concerns surround digital identity: a system described as voluntary must not become indispensable in practice for exercising basic rights.
The Stockholm panel did not present a single technological programme. Its speakers differed over how data should be handled and how far regulation should go. They nevertheless converged on an essential proposition: citizens must not lose control of their freedoms in the name of convenience, security or administrative efficiency.
That proposition offers a challenge for Europe’s conservatives, but also for the Union as a whole. Europe needs innovative companies, strong institutions and the capacity to defend its digital infrastructure. It also needs clear limits on the power of governments and platforms alike.
Sovereignty cannot simply mean transferring more decisions to Brussels. It must mean giving Europeans the ability to innovate, compete and make meaningful choices. A continent that only regulates the inventions of others will remain dependent on them. A continent that sacrifices liberty in pursuit of control will have forgotten what its sovereignty is supposed to defend.